Whose lists
Two community lists were both updated on September 18, 2026, before the Raid Revamp schedule. Polio described an overall-helpfulness list. Darwishgaming1 mixed strength, usefulness, performance, and value. Neither list is an official combat ranking, and neither published a full test method.
This site's tier board keeps only placements where both authors used the same letter. It does not average S and C into a B.
Where they match
Both put Watchman of Doom, Upgraded Titan Clockman, Caine, and Star Fruit in S. Both put Drako, Toilet-Gman, and Soul Fruit in A. Both put King Noobini and Golden Slop Man in C. Both put Dragon Canneloni in D.
Dated damage notes from a September 18 video, not a revamp retest: Watchman of Doom 25,000 DPS, Star Fruit 9,000 DPS with splash and fire, Caine 8,500 DPS with path-spawned bubbles, Soul Fruit 6,250 DPS, Party Cat 3,600 DPS. Party Cat's trade range is much higher than that damage report. Trade value and the letter are different questions.
Splits you should not flatten
Teapot 1x1x1x1 is S on one list and C on the other. Blimp Dragon is S and D. Guest 666 is A and F. Moon Blossom is S on one list and absent on the other. Unranked does not mean weak. Darwishgaming1 also used F and a "better throw it" label. Those labels are not entered on the S–D board.
How to pick
Name the job you are missing: opening damage, a slow, group damage, a hero button, or economy. Moon Blossom is the dated slowing-starter report. Star Fruit and Corgi Poseidon are the dated group-damage and pierce reports. Sahur Statue is the dated buffer report. Watchman of Doom is the dated hero-damage report. Test the live cost and the live stat card. Change one slot at a time so the next clear tells you something.